People who know me would be surprised to see me talk about Estimation, Scheduling and all the related stuff. To be frank I consider that quite boring and better be left alone for managers! However, I am so loving the new process called Scrum we are following for last 6 months, I thought I should write a line or two about it.
Long ago I was reading this article by Joel which talked about doing your scheduling/estimation based on the evidence. What evidence you may ask? If I understood it right, the evidence is your team’s efficiency! Being used to have the people who has no Idea about what the “NEW FEATURE” is and doing the estimation, I kind of liked the idea. How many times have you stayed late in the office to finish the “Cool and Easy” feature that your manager Promised to deliver the next release? I always felt the manager, no matter how experienced or skilled he is, should not be solely responsible for the estimation. We are in the business of programming, and programming is art! Its not the construction business, its not the military. For any work of creativity, you need freedom and comfort. Until we adopted scrum, I was always wondering how the developers can be a part of the whole management thing specially given the lack of interest of the developers in such things.
I am not going to describe what scrum is and what are the common benefits of following scrum, you will find plenty of reference in the net. I’ll just point out what are the things that I think scrum is so effective from estimation point of view and lucrative from a developer’s perspective, So here is my two cents:
1. The Team does the estimation! Your team is composed of people with diverse skill sets. When you throw a new story to a team, at least 2 of the team members would have some kind of idea about how to do it. For some other story, may be some other team members will put their input. So the estimation will be as good as it gets. And after two or three sprints with the similar kind of stories, the estimation should be perfect!
2. The Developers make the Promises! If you are some investor in any software business, and want to have some feature done within a specific time frame, here is a piece of advice from a man in the tranches, ask your developers, not the manager! If a developer commit he will get something done within a specific deadline, he will. We developers are so dumbly proud that we will even sacrifice our personal life to meet the deadline that we promised. On the other hand, if you ask your manager, he will just keep pushing the developers because he can’t do the things himself even he wanted to. That way, you will end up with a buggy and messy product which is the outcome of all the hatred and frustration that your developers produced during the overtime that they did. Scrum does not have a project manager! Scrum has a Scrum master whose responsibility does not include estimation! It is the team who did the promise during your sprint planning that they will accomplish the features. Any self respecting and efficient team will thrive to achieve that. You will be surprised to see the team requesting you to keep the workspace open during the weekend so they can polish the stories for the reviews! Self-management– this is what scrum is all about. In a manager led project, not all the team members share the same responsibility as the manager. Since the manager is solely responsible for all the planning and estimation, other team member doesn’t event feel responsible for the project because they are not at the gun point! This is specially true when the manager tries to accomplish some impossible deadline.
3. The Estimation is based on Evidence! Right after 2 months of following scrum, we kind of knew our team capacity is 80 points per 15 day sprint. After doing 10 sprints, we can now almost 90% accurately tell that if we plan 100 points, we are going to do overtime and we plan 60 points, we will be relaxing! How do we calculate the 80 point? The stories or the tasks that we estimate are constantly compared with the stories or tasks that we did in the previous sprints. We will say, it took us 2 days to do that “user registration form” with all the unit tests and automated tests which was a 5 point story. So we think the “user account detail collection” is a 8 point story which will take 3 days. Simple yet so efficient! One thing about estimation we don’t give much importance is our hunch or intuition! But we develop our ability to “guess” over so many trials and errors! Our subconscious mind is constantly collecting and processing information and our “guess” is the outcome of that. When 6-7 people are guessing something, its the fruit of years of experience that should not be overlooked. It is as close an estimation as you could ever get.
4. Scrum is sustainable! Scrum is by the developers , for the developers :). Forgive my cheap joke, but couldn’t help it ! We are making the estimation, we are making the promises, we decide whats best for the product, we choose the technology, we take the pride! We don’t have a manager to micromanage us, instead we have a scrum master to lead us. We work for ourselves, we work for the team, we work for the product. The satisfaction that this brings us can’t be compared to anything else, no amount of money or facilities can bring this. We don’t feel sick every week, we don’t think we are underpaid, we don’t feel the constant anger, we don’t think about skipping the office each morning, in a word, we don’t burn out! We are happy developers who have fun in the workplace. Believe me, if you want a good product, you don’t need fancy office or fancy furniture or worlds best salary package or even worlds best programmers. You need happy and motivated developers who are smart enough to get the job done. I believe scrum provides the best way to get there.
Having said all these, I must warn that scrum is not for everyone. Scrum is all about self-managed team. That requires highly skilled and seasoned developers who are matured enough to self manage. Scrum requires honesty which is usually not a problem with programmers. Most of all, scrum requires teaming. If your developers can’t jell together, you will end up with highly inefficient team. One of the main reason I feel we could adopt scrum so easily is because each and every developer of the team is quite experienced and has a minimum level of competency. I wonder how we would adopt scrum if we were a bunch of amateurs.